I stumbled upon a very interesting article here on "megachurches"--those churches that comprise thousands of congregates and millions of dollars in their budget, just like Jesus did....oh wait a minute; maybe I have that backwards. Mostly encompassed in the protestant realm, megachurches have grown immensely over the last couple decades with no projected stoppage anywhere in the near future.
As a life-long Christian, I've been in the game a while and have seen and done just about everything that the Christian life and culture has to offer. So much that I'm almost ready to throw in the towel on church attendance altogether or just start showing up at someone's home for a small group study and fellowship. I think it's become quite trendy to rag on the church in general and I always want to stay away from that (or ragging on anyone, since there's ample "material" in my own life). But I gotta wonder if megachurches are really what Christ had in mind when he said "go out from among them".
I think intentions are still mostly good when it comes to these pastors and leadership teams that want to evangelize the world and be the beacons of virtue by seeing the world through God's eyes. However, although God has infinite "wealth", Christ and his followers did not. They were ridiculously poor and totally blue collar. Which means the church didn't start out with the megachurch template. Have they gone terribly awry in their structure? Nothing wrong with money, nothing at all. But when I show up to a megachurch service and I see fog machines on stage (which cost money) and rather brilliant light shows during the "worship" service...I honestly want to puke. There was no showmanship amongst Christ and the early Christians, it was stripped down to bare bones--love God and love you neighbor, just love him! If you can love them with wealth that's great. And please understand there's nothing at all inherently wrong with a performance. I'm a performer and I sleep quite well at night. Nor is a performance totally unrelated to one's spiritual life in my opinion.
But when it comes to organized worship and a time to be meditating on the things above, I don't know, I guess I just find jumbo screens and lazer shows to be completely unspiritual for me. That's fine at a Pink Floyd concert, where, by the way, I find myself being much more spiritually charged (and not because I'm on mushrooms), but in church? Ahhhhhhhh, I just don't know about that.
Some of these pastors have clearly been completely overtaken by the wealth and rock star status that the Christian culture has assigned to them as a result of charismatic personalities, record breaking attendance, and #1 best selling books. Some of these books that are coming out from megachurch pastors are just completely dumbed down "be happy and feel good" pamphlets on how to think positive. They're sluglines at best. I guess even the Christian can sell his soul for a shot at making coin by telling everyone that "it's gonna be okay, God's good." Indeed, I believe he is Good. But this is a very very dull and imcomplete theology that can hurt people as much as it can help people, even more sometimes. I disagree with Marx that religion is merely the opiate of the masses; but he is on to something to some degree. We see it even in the secular world. How to get rich books, how to think positive, THE SECRET, RICH DAD POOR DAD, LIVING THE LIFE YOU'VE ALWAYS DREAMED ABOUT. All of this is religion when you think about it. All of it is based on a world view of how to live your life so that everything is okay. Well, the world is not okay and we ought not be okay with the fact that it's not okay. If you think everything is okay, then you're probably not living a real Christian life. If you're not living with frustration and an ache in your soul for what ought to be, you've missed the whole point of being a Christian.
And it pains me to see this kind of simplicity applied to the Christian life. And I think that's the best word to describe the megachurch culture: simplicity. Milk and honey rather than meat and potatoes. Obviously milk and honey has its place, an infant is going to need those nutrients prior to consuming more substantial food, and a seasoned spiritual person no longer can satiate his hunger for God on milk and honey. But whatever stage we're at, we need to grow up eventually. Megachurches, however, seem to want to grow out. The mentality seems to be "let's get as many infants in here as possible, and just stay put", rather than nuturing these infants where they are and then sending them on to a more rigorous "school" if you will.
Again, it's difficult to evaluate where a pastor's heart is really at, or how much good a church is doing at that size; perhaps a ton, perhaps not so much. But I can't imagine that intimacy, humility, moderation, and the quiet life (all the things that Christ preached), are being tended to in a megachurch. When the mighty dollar overtakes theology and fellowship, you don't have a church anymore, you have a business. Last I checked, Christ was unemployed.
My excellent Conversation with Nate Silver
1 hour ago